see she looks so much better not whited out and looks so mush sexier and healther....
in my opinion she so does not look at all fat..................
yeah Big ups to Tuxman..............................

wow,cool skills fron the t man !! :)

She looks good either way!! You can't tell me you wouldn't slap ugly's w/ her!! She's so 'hot' right now in every sense of the word physical, red carpet, etc. Yo go Scarlett! No problem, thanks for the post & props Bastardly community!

I believe the phrase goes "bump uglies." And yes I would definitely beat her with my man ug.

the original picture looks like it was washed out anyway. Making her more pink doesn't really do anything. I defenitly think she is fine with her white skin. WHY ARE PEOPLE SO AGAINST WHITE SKIN! It can be beautiful! :-(

I think she looks beautiful and real BEFORE.

She's looking a little oompa-loompa like in the retouch...

Cheese anyone? She looks bad in both.

This is crap. I need to see pink or it's not worth it. Um....or something

The original picture - not the one that ended up on the cover - she's not that pale.
I mean yes she's naturaly fair, but they for some reason decided to lighten her even more. I think they were trying to make her look like an old Botticelli painting.

Keira Knightley still looks like she just came out from concentration camp.

i like her very much

She's so damn plain, even with makeup on. Even when she's orange! Very forgetable face too. I knew her only by name before this picture, even tough I've seen her on TV. But I have to give thumbs up to the guy who did the tanning effect. Very well done.

i think she looks ugly in both...i see cellulite!