i don't know why.... yea shes gota cute face but the lower half of her body is like argggggggg cover it up!!!!

There's something about BUTT CRACK, isn't there?

Me? I think she looks like a BABY. I wanna pat some BABY powder on that BABY butt and put a diaper on that BABY who's in a BABY pose. Cute little BABY...

to me she looks like an Aids patient and i think i better appreciated her as actress when she kept her clothes on.

Not really liking this ass. Its just a butt crack, this isn't a real booty.

I don't understand the whole thing with Scarlett being considered so sexy. She looks a bit chunky to me, and really plain. She was so shlumpy in Lost in Translation. She is curvy, has big breasts and lips. Big deal.

I might not be "in the loop" with health, but she is what I consider to be healthy. Her BMI is probably towards the higher end of the normal level for her height, but she is NOT overweight. Keira, on the other hand, looks like she needs to eat something other than celery and diet pills..............

This photo shoot does not help either lady. Keira is a BEAUTIFUL woman but is way too skinny to do this. Scarlett has great curves, but this is not flattering.

Keira, keep the clothes on and keep wearing those beautiful outfits.

Scarlett, just show them so everyone stops talking and you can move on (into oblivion).

i have never understood why people bang on about scarlett, but as i have never watched any of her movies i can not fully judge what she is like other then by occassional still pics and interviews.however on the subject of this photo i think her figure is fine, the only draw back is the colour of her skin, way to whited out.i wonder if she was photoshopped and given a golden tan if peoples perception of her weight and figure would change?be intresting to see?
i think she just looks normal.....
and i didnt think kiera was to thin, you can see some abs going on there............

Hey scar jump in a tanning bed once in a while i know where you can get a ten pack for ten dollors (at sun and skin around my block) but other than that you are hot gurl

Here goes my contribution, I just bought my copy today...Thanks Vanity Fair!!! I like em Squishy, thanks Scarlett for keepin ya body nourished...

Chunky? Geez,not all actresses can be like Nicole Richie.

I think what the people are who have said that Scarlett looks chunky means that she just doesn't have a butt that's DEFINED.....it's like her thighs and butt are just one solid piece of flesh, like her thighs and her butt are ONE. You know? She doesn't have those "dimples" on her lower back which would indicate muscle definition so she obviously doesn't have much muscle. She says she doesn't like to work out so that's why she doesn't have any type of muscle definition, therefore giving her that squishy, baby skin appearance. She does have a moderate amount of body fat on her. She's not fat, she's just not toned.

Nicole Richie is a very short girl and petite framed and should be thin but not as she is now. She could stand to gain 10-15 pounds and build muscle.

Keira is built like me...abs and all. I eat anything I want(I don't starve myself or diet) and they don't go away, I think she's the type(like me) that are just naturally lean...doesn't mean she's not healthy. I do have to say though her horsey mouth bothers me.

what injustice they have done to my beloved scarlette

hot as she is, she is not jessica alba. she doesn't quite have the same... ummm... assets.

having her pose in this position makes no sense. her ass is not that great. have her sit up and do one of them "squeeze my tits together and hide my nipples cause you know, nipples are SOOOO dangerous and if shown will distroy the fabric of our society, but showing the rest of my tits on a newstand is somehow ok" poses. THEN she would appear in her proper hottness.

scarlette, you look shabby in this photo. but its not your fault. you are still gorgeous. bring me the head of that art director!

isnt it weird that the british girl has more of a tan than the gringa?

and also, from her movies (check out the tight pants in Ghost World...) and all, i always assumed that scarlett had kind of a bigger, chunkier (and more beautiful) white girl butt....i dont know, could it have been photoshopped for this picture?

all in all, i still love her!

QUESTION: What is a "white girl" butt?

I am a white female and I've heard this term before, but don't know what it really is/looks like. It sounds kinda fugly and I KNOW I do not have a fugly buttox!

After reading CHEAP TRICK's post again I realized that *duh* he/she had a partial definition of a white girl butt. But chunky is like ghetto booty(which to me is big girl butt, round and large) and white girl butt to me means more of a flat barely there butt....I have more of a shapely and well defined/toned butt. Not chunky or flat.

Scarlett looks quite chubby, Keira is TOO thin.

" What is a “white girl� butt?... It sounds kinda fugly and I KNOW I do not have a fugly buttox!"
That was hilarious. Anyway, I think they must have photoshopped or powdered these girls before the shoot because I don't think anyone is naturally that pasty. Geez. And Scarlett IS lookin' kind pudge in this pic, but then again, she's always been a bit thick. Her body (with the except of the ghostly color) doesn't look terrible, though.

Scarlett looks like a normal woman. She's not afraid to show her curves. Just cause she doesn't fit what you might think is beautiful ( 110 skeletons with every bone showing) doesn't mean she's a fat cow. She's the perfect example of a classic beauty. Now everyone can carry on binge eating and following fad diets.

Scarlett looks like a Greek goddess carved out of marble, or a volumptous Victorian painting. Now that's real beauty...

But I don't think it needs to be on the cover of a trade magazine.

Greek goddess? This has hurt me a bit, since I live close to Greece. She looks like a (slutty, naked) cowgirl painted and made up into something she's really not. I mean, she really has an american face. But I don't get it. Why would I wanna see 2 sluts (one a little on the flat site, the other a little on the chubby) naked and a hot gay guy clothed? Just go to a strip club. Not only do I guarantee you'll see more but it will be of much better quality and live. Could be cheaper, too.

she is very beautiful

This picture is so airbrushed Scarlett doesn't even have a shoulder. She looks like a doughy shoulder-less cartoon.

"I don’t think anyone is naturally that pasty" ~19. Sasha
I know a couple people, including myself, who are naturally that pale. Though I think that is mainly due to the fact we are all very Irish, who are rather well-known for being really fair-skinned.

As for the photo, I think both girls look lovely in their own way. Though, they really do look airbrushed or perhapes it's the photographer's lights. I've noticed, since I am so fair skinned, that if someone uses flash when they take a picture of me, sometimes my skin appears to glow and my features get that white-washed look.

Wow I thought Scarlett was thin! She really needs to lose a few pounds she looks really chubby and puttting her next to gorgeous lithe Keira didn't help either she looks like plump plain girl.

Pfft...take the brit with no assets out of the picture and leave the American bombshell and you got a deal Mac...

She doesn't look fat at all. I agree with a previous post that it's just in the way the picture was taken and edited. I'm sure the photographer saw the shot as magnificent and is kicking himself for over airbrushing it. One more thing...Mary (Jesus's Mother, for those who aren't religious) was said to be more desireable than any woman. She was also milky white. Why do you think men drool over Scarlet? She sexy, all there is to it. You women do the same damn thing to Jennifer Love Hewitt. Women are naturally jealous and prideful towards women who are more beautiful in their own eyes than themselves and will criticise ANYTHING that is just to feel better inside. That's something that women will never change...

I just noticed this in my friends edition of the magazine if you look closely you can see both of the girl's nipples....so in an earlier post i read they didnt even take care to cover that up either. Im a guy so for the idiot that just posted scarlette is really gross pal. how can anyone be attracted to a pale pile of jiggly fat. And kiera has nasty teeth

I really think it's hilarious how all you people can call Scarlett Johansson fat, when you yourselves are all probably burger munching, overweight yanks!

Obviously 90% of the people posting here have been brainwashed into thinking that beautiful = stick-skinny and sun-tanned...I think Scarlett is gorgeous, and because she chooses not to be anorexic and destroy her skin with UV rays does not make her any less beautiful. It would be wonderful if there were more celebrities with healthy-looking figures like hers.

Scarlett is hot. I would take her over someone like Jessica Simpson anyday. Fucking Jessica simpson would be like fucking a tree trunk full of sap. Im sick of all you yank hollywood mother f--kers. Leave scarlett be...maybe then shall we see. (her tits)

peace yo.

Mary was not milky white. Could anybody milky white survive in that part of the world?
Scarlett looks good but if your not toned your but will flatten out when laying down. Keria is too skinny. She doean't look appealing at all. I just don't get it. Scarlette really need to get some sun. Her body is great because she looks normal.

WEll at least she looks better than the baboon jessica alba, and the ugly ratt-face eva longoria.

Nicole Richie is an actress? I think they should have thrown Jessica Alba on the cover with Keira and Scarlett instead of the guy, muuuuch hotter than him.

You people are ridiculous - Scarlett Johansson...FAT? How old are some of you people, 12, 13? Maybe when you become adults you will realize how ridiculous you sound.

While I understand that not everyone may find her attractive, she is definitely not fat. Some of you need to find a more mature and healthier ideal of beauty, because most people are not 110 pounds. Scarlett Johansson is an inspiration - and of normal and healthy weight. She shouldn't feel sorry for choosing not to starve herself, and she shouldn't feel like she has to hide her beautiful body simply because she's not rail thin. I'm extremely glad she chooses to embrace her natural body figure, and I hope she continues to do so in the future. She truly is a real woman.

Man, you have to be kidding me. Maybe it's just because I'm an art student and I see things differently, but I find her paleness attractive. I can't stand fake-bake rail thin teeny boppers. They're all the same person. Scarlett is very old school hollywood glamour...she doesn't walk, she floats...and she's got killer bedroom eyes. In fact, Scarlett Johansson is so fucking beautiful that I'm surprised that the earth hasn't opened up under her feet and swallowed her whole to punish us all for doubting her hotness. The end.

There's too many haters here. Scarlett looks great and I'm sure a hell of a lot better than those of you trashing her

scarlett johansson has a pretty face. for those who say she is ugly, that's an exaggeration. even without makeup, she is probably prettier than many women walking down the street with makeup. i think many people don't find her absolutely beautiful because she isn't the over tanned, anorexic woman we are used to calling beautiful. she has curves and a porcelain complection...now picture a beautiful, over tanned, anorexic woman...now picture them with porcelain skin and an extra fifteen pounds...how many so called beautiful people can pull that off and look better than scarlett johansson???

I agree that Scarlett looks SO beautiful here. I thoroughly agree with the art student. I cannot comprehend how you can't see her beauty. She looks so soft and alluring. She is luminescent and her face is enticing. Keira on the other hand looks somehow wrong in this picture. The toned abs look odd.

TITLE PARMIGIANINO G F M MAZZOLA 1503

BASE GOUFFRE DE PADIRAC 1999 MAGIE DE LA GOUTTE D EAU

RESEAU COPERNICO MAZZA F 1992
ATLAS LIGUISTIK F GILLIERON H CHAMPION 1906
CODE NOIR LE MAUVAIS OEIL CLAPISSON
OEIL DES ROIS LIT DE JUSTICE 1584 BORDEAUX

ISSUE IL MAESTRO DI CAMERA SESTINE F 1628

the guy should be 'nude' too....