KATHERINE

Katherine is much cuter and has more class in the way she dresses, talks, and sings in my opinion.

Like I said before, Pickler always looks unnatural (and in pain) when she smiles. Just look at page three. Katherine has a nice, natural smile and Pickler has a painful, stretched smile. Smiling is not just seeing how wide you can stretch your mouth! I also like Katherine's eyebrows and the fact that her hair is it's natural color. There's not really any one feature that I don't like about her.

Pickler definitely loses this matchup! How Simon thinks she is a "minx" (not MINK... MINX) is beyond me!

The brunette.

Katharine...i like em thick. She got a nice booty and pretty face...

Katharine is much prettier.

kellies hotter.. katharines prettier.. i think kellies body is awesome too.. but katharines got a prettier face

I like the photo of them hugging and pressing their tits together.... Now if we could only get them to kiss...

Katharine is cuter. Definitely.

Katharine has a beautiful face, and a nice thick booty for a white girl.

Kellie has a bigger onion booty Carlito...

As a result, Kellie wins.

LA girl = botox.
NC girl = inbreeding.

And this is why the space between these gals' eyebrows won't move.

Kelly gets my vote. I would say Katharine if she didn't look so bloated and didn't have shoulders like a high school football player.

yeah, they could go lez, look like they get off on each other

I agree with badmammajamma, they are both cute but in an ordinary way. Other than that I can't comment, I think American Idol is a trendy piece of crap so I don't know about their siging abilities.

C'mon, peeps... Katharine is way hotter... and this is coming from a girl!

Kellie is cute and all, and has a great figure, but Katharine is much better looking, hands-down. She's got a great figure, she's tall, and she has a gorgeous face. Please, no contest.

I would rather date Kellie

I have to go with Kelli. Katherine looks too much like her mother in the face, and if you ever see her mom out in the audience you'll know what I am talking about, ugh!

Kelli is pretty and I like her body better than Katherine. I think Katherine is hiding something with her body in the middle. She always wears big clothes there, and when they are tighter in the middle, she wears something like a v vest to slim her down. Some kinda blubber going on there. Hate the nose on her, and the long chin. Gotta go with Kelli!

Jeff ,24
California

katharine all the way she is way hotter than kellie, she also is a way better singer than kellie

Kellie is a joke. Katherine has all the qualities of someone who will draw a wider audience. Kellie is limited to... you know country music, what a surprise.

i like katherines booty but i like pickler's juicy boobs! i like em both

they are both hot!

NEITHER!

Kellie's cute, but Katharine is gorgeous! But I love them both and I wish Katharine would have won!!

Kellie is way prettier than Katherine in my opinion.

Kelli is the best i stopped watching after she got voted off.She should have one YOU ROCK she is so hot.Hotter than kat.girl shake that thing over here.

kat's my baby, but kellie can get it too...i'd like to knock both of them off together b/c they're both appealing sexually & i can handle them like they need...they can gladly alternate between my face & shaft & everyone cums out a winner...see, easy solution...

There's really no comparison, except that Pickler pales in comparison of the goddess known as Katharine McPhee. Kat is perfect, her body, face, legs, ass, boobs, body, face, boobs, did I say that already? In short, Katharine McTatas McPhee blows what's her face out of the water.

tough, but Kellie Pickler

KATH IS HORRIBLE!!!!!!!!!!!!

Katharine hands down. The big boobs, the perfect booty, the gorgeous face! Perfection!

Well, they're both cute. However, they're both cute in an ordinary sort of way. There's nothing unique or striking about either one of them. That being said, I think Katherine is prettier.