Creaky, #11 did not say they like broad shoulders and narrow hips was what he liked. I agree with #11, hips are great and without them you don't have a figure but if you have hips you have to have a balance in the shoulders. If you look at her from just the waist down you would think she was bigger on top. If you look at her from the waist up you would think her hips would be a tad smaller, IMO. It's not hips that are bad it's proportion.