McPhee by a landslide.

mcphee is my "type" but i have the feeling heigl is a better bang

McPhee, but both are gorgeous :)

McPhee: she is just stunning.

Oh man, k. heigl should stop smoking. She used to be hawt, but is so thin nowadays.

Both be pretty fugly.

Heigl. Classic and she's going to be around awhile. McPhee is just another Idol wannabe.

wow... really tough call. great match-up. mcphee is more my type, but her linebacker-esque shoulders move her down a few notches. heigl it is!

Mcphee it is!!!
Katherine Heigl's teeth have always annoyed me, and Mcphee is just perfection.

Absolutely McPhee. Heigl looks really odd (and old) in most of her pictures and only occasionally hot. Katherine McPhee is consistently smokin hot.

plus McPhee looks like a retarded harp seal in that second picture
where the hell is my hakapik?

Can't make a fair vote until I give both a shot of man gravy and see which one takes it the best.....then I vote

Another vote for McPhee and her big dark eyes...

I feel sorry for Heigl (when she was younger...), but her divergent strabismus is more evident everyday.

McPhee all the way. See how beautiful she is even without makeup , try that, Heigl, nd she is athletic and fit too - watch her do cartwheels and handstands and look very sexy on a horse: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5UoyhW2ltX8

A total fucking dream lez-pairing if I've ever seen one.

KMP's got that whole young Kat Zeta-J thing going on & I've wanted to fuck Kat H ever since Roswell High.

Look at the hairline of Heigl. Bad colorist!

Is McPhee still working on her 15 minutes? Oh, okay I'll take her. That other one looks a tad bit scary there for some reason. Is Heigl supposed to be hot? Heimlich is more like it.

If the carpet matches the drapes, I'll take the red one....I haven't had that in a while.

The brunette takes the prize.

Bonus points to McPhee for the sexy shoes.

Mcphee for sure. very foxy. kinda has a rachel bilson look about her with the hair and eyes. yeah..the smoking thing is catching up with heigl, she's on her way to looking like a walking catcher's mitt.

McPhee hands down. My god she is sexy!

Heigel back when she was a teenager.

lol at all the losers from idolforums and other kat boards defending mcphee. more like mcflop. FUCK MCPHEE.

more or less the same, but the left one wins

heigl is prettier, tho mcphee isn't bad.

Mcphee. She's tighter, and hasn't had any real success yet, so she'll be desperate.

this is pretty easy
McPhee was on Idol and she
lost to the 50 year old jay leno look alike
so she's not even good at being shity
and she was about 30 lbs heavier on the show than she is now
so she is a bad day away from becoming a full blown anorexic
or breaking out the hagen daz and turning into Charlotte Church
which is all a round about way to say she is a mess
Heigl on the other hand threatened to kick the shit out of Issac Washington
for calling her boy TR Knight a fag
and chicks fighting is superhot
Heigl IN!

Two of my favortites girls:

Mcphee is perfection to me
Heigl is super fuckin' hot also