i dont know why or what it is but i dont find her remotely attractive... she doesnt do a thing for me and i think shes the most overrated person ever

john, i was going to post the same thing. i thought i was the only one. she's got a great rack, and i'd obviously hit that, but as far as celebs go, i just don't get the hype. overall, she's very average.

It's because she looks like a million other girls you see everywhere. nothing enticing, just another blonde

Eh....I just saw this movie called Match Point that she was in. I must say, she's really cute on film and she is a good actress. In pictures I didn't quite "get it" either, although she is definitely photogenic. I really think it's more of a talent thing.

she sounds like a dude and kinda looks like one. a dude with a nice rack mind you,but a dude none the less.

I don't know. I think sometimes we find fault with celebrities just to be funny or something. My criteria is that if this was just a regular girl walking down the street would I holla at her? And I would. I find it hard to believe that most of us wouldn't.

She's gorgeous. The only complaint I have with these photos is that Vogue never changes the style of photography. That's annoying.

But Scarlett looks amazing on page 2.

Sullen Girl

She’s gorgeous. The only complaint I have with these photos is that Vogue never changes the style of photography. That’s annoying.

But Scarlett looks amazing on page 2.

as usual, your SO right. i love scarlett, i think shes beautiful, and an awesome actress, not overrated at all.

News Flash! 99% of guys would F anything, be it a celeb or not. Thanks, Management.

She might be overrated. But she is not as overrated as Halley Barry.

i usually love her in photos but what the fuck she looks absolutely hideous on the cover. i cant believe thats her. eugh.

She's jaw-droppingly beautiful. My balls ache.

@9... Those DSL's of hers are nothing without the "Whore Red Dickstick"

' i can dress in whatever i want. besides, some fellows like me.'
what the fuck does that even mean?? she annoys me.

She's a terrible actress with no range. And a goony face.

Oooh. I want that corset.

I'm sooo bored with her. She never has anything to say that isn't predictable. I read 3 different mags and they've all had her recently. I'm sure she's done many others. Overexposure.

She's also very full of herself, a very unlikable person I'm tired of. NEXT

she looks airbrushed like all the other actresses. She's not that skinny

looks rather assless

Nah. She's had better shoots

bleh she is not hot at all.

Overrated and overly yuppie-exposed-NewYork-calculatedeccentric, etc., she cerainly is.

These are the reasons the public loves her:
a. she has an hourglass shape. vogue would like to call it "curvy" but "curvy" to them is anyone who doesn't look like Jessica Miller, the skeletor from the previous post. I subscribe. They like using the term "fleshy" as well as "curvy" to describe people who are not skeletors, i.e. Linda Evangelista, many socialites who range from size 2 to 8 and pretty much all 90s models, Kate Moss withstanding.
b) more on her shape. NEWSFLASH: all straight men and some gay men are excited by hourglass shaped women.
c) she's not paris hilton, lindsay lohan, etc. she knows how to behave and for a 21 yr old actress these days, that's very rare
d) she's not quite as vapid as other actresses.
e) she doesn't censor herself at all so there's generally something in all her interviews to raise eyebrows.

I agree with TOM and DARIA (AGAIN)....I mean...we have these expectations of what we think a "celebrity" is supposed to look like...Everyone says "she's just an average girl"...Exactly...no one said celebrities were superhuman. Seriously, you guys know that you would holla at her. If I was a guy, or a lesbian, I would! The reasons why she generates so much attention, is that she is one of the only woman in hollywood whom has a body that looks close to what the average American looks like. You don't have to think she's gorgeous, or hot or whatever...but you gotta agree, that is something to rave about...I mean...when is the last time you've heard an actress say "I'm not a size 2 and i'm okay with it", Hardly ever. I respect her for that, and that alone.

looks a bit like Marilyn Manson in the first picture, which is more than a little bit offputting

[...] Many think Scarlett Johansson is overrated. Her looks are not that remarkable. But I think this girl is really something. She is not the prettiest among the girls in Hollywood but she has this thing called X-Factor that made her totally different from her counterparts. She is oozing with hotness and this cover pic of Vogue is unfortunately not showing any of that. If you want more pics of her in the April 2007 issue of Vogue magazine, then you may as well view them all here. [...]

Hurl!!!

say what you will, bastards! i think she's gorgeous... scarlett seems to have her head on straight and has a lot of edginess about her. plus, she's all of 21 and has avoided so many bad teen movies which i'm sure would've earned her more $$$ and exposure, in favor of woody allen flicks and period pieces. not feeling her lipstick on the cover, though.

nice big tits, but other than that - I just don't see the fuss

Totally over rated ,crap faced 0000000000000gly gal ,I HATE HER HATE HER HATE HER :x

i m from india...........i m biggest fan of scarlett.............please tell me how can i get this vogue magazine....

Wow, Scarlett is getting some serious flack here. I absolutely adore her, and I apparently must explain why, to all of these detractors. She is just so curvy! She looks how a sexy woman should look. Most Hollywood starlets are too skinny, without hips or enough boobs, but Scarlett has ample amounts of hips and boobs. And her face is so delicately structured, and her lips are amazing, and her slightly slanted eyes are tantalizing. Basically, she's a gorgeous, curvy, classic yet modern blonde bombshell. I'm not sure how people are missing all of this, unless they're just too focused on the overly skinny, not-curvy-enough starlets.

I suppose there's no accounting for taste. However, I fancy her and would enjoy doing things with her that would be illegal in nearly every Southern state.

overrateeeedddd... theres a million other hotter celebrities

[...] Scarlett Johansson does Vogue Magazine. [Bastardly] [...]

horse face or pigface, I'm not sure, but either way she really is a homely one. So tired of everyone kissing her ass. She's not as ugly as Tori Spelling, but she's ugly in her own right.

She's got those huge, luscious African lips. They're better than Jolie's. Plus she's got a generous bosom. She's the bomb.

umm shes ok here, but she can look better... i dont like the first picture. and yes overrated

Mr. Chubby wishes to dissent by saying SJ is a classic blonde bombshell and one of the most talented actors for her age group in Hollywood. She reminds us of a young Jessica Lange. We look forward to seeing her in pictures for years to come.